Skip to content
NEVER STOP EXPERIMENTINGGet the book
Menu

Technique 21 of 31

The Propositions Generator

Discover strategies for crafting irresistible proposals.

  • Negotiation
  • Value Creation
  • Flexibility

In short

The Propositions Generator prepares at least three proposals before a negotiation, so talks don’t stall on a single dimension such as price. It uses six dimensions of value (material or non-material, certain or probable, immediate or deferred, ecological or non-ecological, fixed or floating, absolute or multiplying) and five steps to combine them into proposals.

For: Anyone preparing a negotiation, from team leads to executives

The Problem

Through my Agile transformation work, I saw negotiations fail because they fixated on a single value dimension—like price or position—ignoring other possibilities. This rigid approach often led to deadlocks, frustration, and lost opportunities.123

The Experiment

To overcome this, I worked with teams and leaders to develop the Propositions Generator, a technique that expands negotiation scope by generating at least three proposals before discussions begin. By considering factors like timing, long-term benefits, and trade-offs, we shifted negotiations from rigid standoffs to collaborative problem-solving—leading to more creative and mutually beneficial agreements.45

What Are the Universally Significant Dimensions of Value?

Outlined below are six universal dimensions of value that I have discovered throughout my experience. These dimensions provide significant flexibility during negotiations and can guide us toward mutually beneficial outcomes.6

To illustrate these dimensions, let’s use a simple scenario.

Suppose you have a meeting with an employee to discuss a salary update. You anticipate their salary expectations to be a 25% increase, which you believe is reasonable given their efforts and accomplishments. However, you have set a maximum limit of 15% for potential salary increases.

A man in a shirt and tie sits across a desk from a woman holding a sheet of paper, who raises a finger as she speaks. Above them float the options on the table: a palm tree and beach umbrella with “15%”, a ringing phone, a clock, a money bag with a “$” sign, a rosette medal, a rising zigzag arrow with “25%”, and a car with “10%”.

Entering the meeting without any alternatives will likely result in a bargaining situation, leaving one of the parties dissatisfied.7

What alternative choices do you have available?

Material vs. Non-material Value

Typically, our focus revolves around the material dimension of value, such as the percentage increase in salary. However, by identifying non-material values, we can introduce alternative propositions.8

  • As an example, an alternative option to consider in the given scenario is to offer non-material benefits instead of a salary increase. This could include flexible working hours, remote work opportunities, and an extra ten days of paid annual leave. For some individuals, this option might be more appealing than a material increase of 25%, and the associated costs for the organization may remain below the 15% limit.910
  • An additional option involves a combination of material and non-material aspects. For instance, consider the following proposal: a 25% salary increase in exchange for irregular working hours, where the person would be on call 24/7 to address any immediate needs. This way, the organization offsets the material loss with non-material compensation.

Certain vs. Probable Value

Based on my observations, individuals vary in their preferences between opting for “less, but certain” or “more, but contingent on uncertain conditions.”11 With this in mind, we can introduce two new proposals to the meeting example:

  • Certain Value: Offer a guaranteed 10% increase without any conditions.
  • Probable Value: Offer a 25% monthly bonus, contingent upon achieving predetermined results.

Immediate vs. Deferred Value

Individuals also vary in their preference for immediate rewards or deferred benefits.121314 In the given example, consider the following proposals:

  • Immediate Value: Provide a 10% increase, effective immediately from the next paycheck.
  • Deferred Value: Offer a 25% increase upon completing the ongoing project, expected to conclude within six months.

Ecological vs. Non-ecological Value

This dimension examines whether the value proposition brings any negative side effects.1516

  • Ecological Value: Offer a 15% increase while retaining their company phone and brand-new company car, with the associated expenses covered by the organization.
  • Non-ecological Value: Present a 25% increase, contingent upon surrendering their company phone and car, partially compensating for the substantial salary raise.

Fixed vs. Floating Value

Consider whether the value remains constant or fluctuates based on certain factors.17 For example:

  • Fixed Value: Apply an immediate 15% increase that will be reflected in all future monthly payments, ensuring a consistent and predictable income moving forward.
  • Floating Value: Offer the employee 10% of the profit generated by their department, resulting in variable compensation that may significantly exceed the expected 25% increase in some months.

Absolute vs. Multiplying Value

Evaluate whether the value has the potential to grow over time or remains stagnant.1819 For instance:

  • Absolute Value: Extend a 15% increase that remains constant, even considering potential inflationary impacts.
  • Multiplying Value: Offer company options in place of a salary increase, allowing for exponential growth over time, potentially exceeding the 25% salary increase multiple times.

Are You Ready to Close the Deal?

The Propositions Generator is a straightforward approach that helps us generate diverse and compelling proposals before and during negotiations. It consists of the following steps:

  1. Identify possible options for each dimension. Begin by brainstorming and identifying possible options for each of the six dimensions of value. Explore different alternatives within the material and non-material value, certain and probable value, immediate and deferred value, ecological and non-ecological value, fixed and floating value, and absolute and multiplying value dimensions.
  2. Identify constraints when combining options. Consider any constraints or limitations that may arise when combining different options. For instance, certain options may be incompatible or contradictory. Take note of these constraints to ensure coherent and viable proposals.
  3. Create combinations without violating constraints. Next, focus on creating combinations of options that do not violate the constraints identified in Step 2. The objective is to generate a wide range of potential proposal combinations while adhering to the defined restrictions.
  4. Select proposals to initiate negotiations. Evaluate the combinations from Step 3 and select the proposals that possess the greatest potential for success in winning over the other party. It is recommended to have a minimum of three strong proposals before entering into important negotiations.20
  5. Adapt and modify proposals during negotiations. Remain flexible during the negotiation process. Remember that the proposals initially presented are not set in stone. Refer back to the full list of generated options to better accommodate and reflect the opposing party’s preferences, ensuring a dynamic and responsive approach.21

References

  1. R. Fisher, W. Ury, and B. Patton, Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In, 3rd ed. (Penguin Books, 2011).
  2. M. H. Bazerman and M. A. Neale, Negotiating Rationally (Free Press, 1992).
  3. J. K. Sebenius, Negotiate Smarter, Not Harder: Make Better Deals and Reach Agreement Faster (Harvard Business Review, 2017).
  4. L. Thompson, The Mind and Heart of the Negotiator, 7th ed. (Pearson, 2020).
  5. M. H. Bazerman and D. A. Moore, Judgment in Managerial Decision Making, 8th ed. (Wiley, 2012).
  6. D. A. Lax and J. K. Sebenius, 3-D Negotiation: Powerful Tools to Change the Game in Your Most Important Deals (Harvard Business Review Press, 2006).
  7. J. R. Curhan, H. A. Elfenbein, and H. Xu, “What Do People Value When They Negotiate? Mapping the Domain of Subjective Value in Negotiation,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 91, no. 3 (2006): 493–512.
  8. E. L. Deci and R. M. Ryan, Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior (Springer, 1985).
  9. E. E. Kossek and B. A. Lautsch, “Work-Life Flexibility for Whom? Occupational Status and Work-Life Inequality in Upper, Middle, and Lower-Level Jobs,” Academy of Management Annals 12, no. 1 (2018): 5–36.
  10. J. M. Brett and L. Thompson, “Negotiation: Behavioral Perspectives,” in International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 2nd ed., ed. James D. Wright (Elsevier, 2015): 458-465.
  11. D. Kahneman and A. Tversky, “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision Under Risk,” Econometrica 47, no. 2 (1979): 263–91.
  12. S. Frederick, G. Loewenstein, and T. O’Donoghue, “Time Discounting and Time Preference: A Critical Review,” Journal of Economic Literature 40, no. 2 (2002): 351–401.
  13. G. Ainslie, “Specious Reward: A Behavioral Theory of Impulsiveness and Impulse Control,” Psychological Bulletin 82, no. 4 (1975): 463–96.
  14. G. Loewenstein and D. Prelec, “Anomalies in Intertemporal Choice: Evidence and an Interpretation,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 107, no. 2 (1992): 573–97.
  15. L. M. Ellram, “Total Cost of Ownership: An Analysis Approach for Purchasing,” International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management 25, no. 8 (1995): 4–23.
  16. G. T. Milkovich, J. M. Newman, and B. Gerhart, Compensation, 11th ed. (McGraw-Hill Education, 2013).
  17. E. P. Lazear, “Personnel Economics: Past Lessons and Future Directions,” Journal of Labor Economics 17, no. 2 (1999): 199–236.
  18. B. J. Hall and K. J. Murphy, “Stock Options for Undiversified Executives,” Journal of Accounting and Economics 33, no. 1 (2002): 3–42.
  19. P. Oyer, and S. Schaefer, “Why Do Some Firms Give Stock Options to All Employees? An Empirical Examination of Alternative Theories,” Journal of Financial Economics 76, no. 1 (2005): 99–133.
  20. K. W. Valley, M. A. Neale, and E. A. Mannix, “Friends, Lovers, Colleagues, Strangers: The Effects of Relationships on the Process and Outcome of Dyadic Negotiations,” in Research on Negotiation in Organizations, vol. 5, ed. R. J. Bies, R. J. Lewicki, and B. H. Sheppard (JAI Press, 1995): 65–93.
  21. W. W. Maddux, E. Mullen, and A. D. Galinsky, “Chameleons Bake Bigger Pies and Take Bigger Pieces: Strategic Behavioral Mimicry Facilitates Negotiation Outcomes,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 44, no. 2 (2008): 461–68.

From Never Stop Experimenting by Stavros Stavru, PhD, illustrated by Iva Grueva. Published here in full on .

How to cite this technique

Stavru, S. (2025). The Propositions Generator. In Never Stop Experimenting: 31 Real-World Experiments for Continuous Growth in Work and Life. Morgan James Publishing. https://neverstopexperimenting.com/techniques/propositions-generator

One new experiment, now and then

New techniques, real-world results and behind-the-scenes stories from Stavros. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.